Where Do You Stand On Capital Punishment

The real "Old Sparky" electric chair...
Image by loraxsix via Flickr

Everything changed on  July 23, 2007 for William Petit, a prominent Connecticut endocrinologist and his wife Jennifer Hawke-Petit and two daughters. A middle of the night home invasion. left Dr. Petit badly beaten and his wife and two daughters, abused sexually and physically for 7 hours at the hands of Steven Hayes and another accomplice. The two accomplices fled, after dousing the Petit home with gasoline and setting it ablaze.

On November 10, after nearly three days of deliberation, a jury found Steven Hayes guilty on 16 of the 17 charges and recommended the death penalty for each count. Several states in the USA support the death penalty while others have abolished it.  The case remains that housing a prisoner is expensive and some statistics show it may be anywhere from $62-75/daily but putting an individual on death wrong sometimes often means years of appeals. Steven Hayes can expect to not have his penalty carried out for maybe ten or more years.  During that time, the appeals process can skyrocket to a million or more dollars. Crime it seems does cost…taxpayers that is…and plenty regardless if a person is sent to prison for life or is given a death penalty sentence.

A prison Cell

Image via Wikipedia

Many argue that prisons are definitely overcrowded and abolishing the death penalty would mean that another bed was occupied for the rest of someone’s life, yet the few people put to death each year hardly would free up a sizable amount of beds. Our prison system is stressed and whether you are for or against capital punishment doesn’t fix the appeals system that takes decades while we continue to pay for the time and effort of litigators seeking to absolve an issue already decided by a jury.

The bible strictly commands, “thou shalt not kill”. It would seem that the cost to keep someone imprisoned for the rest of life is substantial, but allowing someone to continue to file appeal after appeal, while awaiting their death also costs significant money and prohibits an attorney from attending to another case.

People should most certainly pay for their crimes. Sometimes death is the least traumatic. Steven Hayes has attempted suicide many times and has indicated he wanted to be put to death. Isn’t it more far more painful  to have to spend the remainder of your life in a confined environment, with no contact with others, awaiting your true death when decided by God. Yes, it could be decades, upon decades. Loneliness and abandonment, lack of freedom and routine can be tortuous as well.

We need to change our appeals system. Christians need to have a moral compass but that doesn’t mean we need to be soft or easy on criminals. I believe a person who has committed a heinous act and is found guilty should be given life without parole, without appeals, without amenities except for the basic things to minimally survive, end of story.

It is a slap in the face to jurors who try to make wise decisions to have their recommendations overturned by over zealous litigators and archaic laws that permit  extensions, injunctions, appeals and interventions.  I don’t believe we should kill a killer anymore than most people believe we should rape a rapist, but I do believe that the slow painful passing your life minute by minute knowing nothing will ever change in a small cell without ever gaining freedom can be a punishment that fits the crime perhaps even better than an injection to end the emotional suffering.

Let’s continue to punish those who have justifiably been convicted, but not with capital punishment. Let’s not give attorneys an opportunity to request appeals and drag on a process that may never end in death at the expense of our taxpayers.  If I am going to pay to keep someone behind bars, then I want to know that is where they will be without any hope of any appeal, ever getting out or any pardon. Justice not vengeance would prevail.

Granted there are people imprisoned who have served time but are innocent and I would want monies to go to help those individuals to gain their freedom.  I support the The Innocence Project but in cases like Steven Hayes where there is no question of guilt, I support life without parole and without much more than what is needed to survive another day with your conscience and the knowledge that your choices put you where you are.

How about you what is your opinion on Capital Punishment and our current judicial system?

About Kathy Brunner

Author, Speaker, Fire-starter. Believe anyone can make their passion happen and create a life On Purpose and With Intention. I can show you how to re-invent your life to go from Burned Out to Fired Up. Are you ready to REALLY live your dreams?
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Where Do You Stand On Capital Punishment

  1. Charles Johnson says:

    I thought I was a proponent of capitol punishment until I read your post. I never thought of the cost of the legalities that goes with the death sentence. And, I never thought of the torment that a life in confinement would bring. If we could just take away the “rights” of the criminal, perhaps our society would be safer and our tax dollares spent a little more wisely.

    Based on the information on your post, I would agree that the death penalty is not the way to go. Let them live and feel the real torture for the crime.


  2. Nina says:

    Possibly a means to have a decrease in crime is to take on the philosophy:
    It is not the severity of the punishment as it is the assurity. If criminals know for certain of the punishement they will “without a doubt” receive it may cause a change in their decision. I have no hesitation in supporting putting those to death who took a death. I am a health care provider of over twenty years and understand and value human life.


    • Nina,

      Thank you for your response. I also have a value and respect for life from working in the health care field. Capital Punishment seems to take on different perspectives when looked at from more than a single lens. Please continue to follow the blog and I would like to have your input on the other issues as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s